The coloration noticed in many types of Malus domestica arises primarily from the presence of anthocyanins, a kind of flavonoid pigment. These water-soluble pigments are synthesized within the fruit’s pores and skin throughout ripening, notably when uncovered to daylight. Their focus determines the depth of the noticed hue.
The event of those pigments serves a number of necessary features for the plant. These embody safety towards ultraviolet radiation, attracting pollinators and seed dispersers by visible signaling, and contributing to the fruit’s antioxidant properties. Traditionally, deeper shades have been related to increased ranges of helpful compounds, influencing shopper desire and agricultural breeding packages.
The particular genetic components and environmental circumstances, similar to temperature fluctuations and lightweight publicity, affect the manufacturing and accumulation of those pigments. These components and circumstances result in the colourful exterior attribute that influences shopper notion and market worth.
1. Anthocyanin Manufacturing
Anthocyanin manufacturing is the first biochemical course of liable for the coloration noticed in many types of apples. Its presence and focus instantly correlate with the depth of the fruit’s outer colour, offering the reply to “why are apples pink”.
-
Genetic Regulation of Anthocyanin Biosynthesis
The biosynthesis of anthocyanins is tightly regulated by a fancy community of genes that encode enzymes concerned within the anthocyanin biosynthetic pathway. These genes are sometimes transcriptionally activated by particular regulatory proteins in response to environmental alerts. Completely different apple cultivars possess various genetic predispositions for anthocyanin manufacturing, resulting in variations of their coloration. For instance, cultivars with mutations in key regulatory genes could exhibit diminished or absent colour even below optimum rising circumstances.
-
Affect of Environmental Components on Anthocyanin Accumulation
Environmental components similar to daylight, temperature, and water availability can considerably influence anthocyanin accumulation in apple pores and skin. Daylight, notably ultraviolet (UV) radiation, acts as a potent inducer of anthocyanin synthesis. Decrease temperatures in the course of the ripening stage also can promote anthocyanin manufacturing, resulting in a extra intense coloration. Conversely, excessive temperatures and water stress can inhibit anthocyanin synthesis, leading to much less vibrant fruit.
-
Function of Sugar Metabolism in Anthocyanin Formation
Anthocyanin biosynthesis is intently linked to sugar metabolism, as sugars present the carbon skeleton and power required for the manufacturing of those pigments. Excessive sugar concentrations within the fruit tissue can stimulate anthocyanin synthesis, whereas low sugar ranges can restrict pigment formation. The effectivity of sugar transport and metabolism throughout the fruit influences the general anthocyanin content material and, consequently, the depth.
-
Impression of Pre- and Put up-Harvest Dealing with on Anthocyanin Stability
Pre-harvest components like orchard administration practices, together with pruning and fertilization, can affect anthocyanin ranges. Put up-harvest dealing with, similar to storage temperature and length, also can have an effect on the soundness of anthocyanins. Improper storage circumstances can result in pigment degradation, leading to a lack of fruit colour. Sustaining optimum storage circumstances is essential for preserving the visible enchantment of apples all through their shelf life.
In abstract, anthocyanin manufacturing is a multifaceted course of involving genetic regulation, environmental influences, sugar metabolism, and dealing with practices. Its intricate interaction finally determines the colour of the apple, considerably impacting its visible enchantment and market worth. The variations in these components account for the wide selection of pink hues noticed throughout totally different apple varieties, reinforcing the central function of anthocyanins in figuring out “why are apples pink”.
2. Daylight Publicity
Daylight publicity is a vital determinant within the improvement of the attribute coloration in lots of apple varieties. The method of anthocyanin synthesis, which instantly dictates the depth of the pink hue, is considerably stimulated by direct or oblique publicity to photo voltaic radiation, notably the ultraviolet (UV) element. This phenomenon explains the frequent commentary of a extra intensely coloured aspect on the fruit instantly going through the solar. As an illustration, apples grown in shaded orchard places usually exhibit a much less pronounced or uneven colour distribution in comparison with these with optimum mild interception. The shortage of ample daylight reduces the activation of genes liable for anthocyanin manufacturing, instantly impacting the visible look.
The depth of the pink coloration just isn’t solely depending on the length of daylight publicity but in addition on its depth. Increased mild intensities usually end in larger anthocyanin accumulation. Moreover, the timing of publicity is critical; daylight publicity in the course of the later levels of fruit ripening has a extra pronounced impact on colour improvement than publicity early within the rising season. Business apple growers usually make use of pruning methods to maximise mild penetration throughout the tree cover, instantly addressing the necessity for sufficient daylight to realize the specified vibrant look. Reflective floor covers are additionally used to extend mild publicity to the decrease parts of the fruit, additional enhancing coloration.
In abstract, the connection between daylight publicity and colour improvement is direct and well-established. The diploma and timing of photo voltaic radiation instantly affect the biochemical pathways liable for producing the pigments that give apples their attribute hues. Whereas genetic components set the potential for colour improvement, daylight acts as the first set off for realizing that potential. Subsequently, optimum daylight administration is essential in producing apples with the visually interesting pink colour anticipated by customers, thereby influencing marketability and financial worth.
3. Genetic Components
The inherent capability of an apple selection to develop a pink coloration is essentially decided by its genetic make-up. Particular genes management the enzymes concerned within the anthocyanin biosynthesis pathway. The presence or absence of those genes, in addition to variations of their regulatory areas, dictate whether or not an apple will produce anthocyanins, and if that’s the case, the amount and particular kind. For instance, cultivars like ‘Pink Scrumptious’ possess genetic traits that strongly promote anthocyanin synthesis, leading to a deeply coloured fruit below favorable environmental circumstances. Conversely, ‘Golden Scrumptious’, regardless of its title, lacks the genetic predisposition to provide vital quantities of anthocyanins, therefore its yellow hue. This distinction exemplifies the direct affect of genetic components on the noticed coloration. The inheritance of those genetic traits follows Mendelian ideas, influencing breeding methods aimed toward creating new varieties with desired colour traits.
Additional complexity arises from the polygenic nature of colour inheritance. A number of genes usually work together to find out the ultimate phenotype. Minor variations in these genes can result in refined variations in colour depth or hue. Molecular markers linked to color-related genes are more and more utilized in marker-assisted choice, permitting breeders to determine seedlings with the specified genetic potential early within the breeding course of, thus accelerating the event of latest apple cultivars. Moreover, epigenetic modifications, which alter gene expression with out altering the underlying DNA sequence, also can play a job. These modifications may be influenced by environmental components and contribute to phenotypic variation inside a genetically uniform inhabitants.
In conclusion, genetic components characterize the foundational determinant of “why are apples pink.” They dictate the potential for anthocyanin manufacturing, whereas environmental components act as modulators of this inherent potential. Understanding the genetic foundation of fruit colour is important for apple breeders searching for to enhance fruit high quality and shopper enchantment. Challenges stay in totally elucidating the advanced interactions between genes and the atmosphere. Continued analysis in genomics, transcriptomics, and metabolomics is essential for gaining a complete understanding of the genetic management of fruit coloration and its response to environmental cues, providing insights into “why are apples pink.”
4. Ripening Stage
The ripening stage constitutes a vital juncture within the improvement of coloration in lots of apple varieties. Anthocyanin synthesis, the first driver of pink pigmentation, is considerably upregulated throughout ripening. Because the fruit transitions from its immature inexperienced state, enzymatic actions throughout the fruit improve, resulting in the manufacturing of the pink pigments. This course of is usually correlated with the degradation of chlorophyll, additional revealing the underlying hues. The initiation and development of ripening present the biochemical context for the synthesis and accumulation of anthocyanins, making it a central consider understanding “why are apples pink”.
The depth and uniformity of colour improvement are intrinsically linked to the synchronization of ripening processes throughout the fruit. Uneven ripening may end up in non-uniform coloration, lowering market worth. As an illustration, if some elements of an apple ripen quicker than others, these areas will exhibit a extra intense pink hue in comparison with the much less mature areas. Components similar to ethylene manufacturing, sugar accumulation, and cell wall modifications, which characterize ripening, instantly affect the activation of genes concerned in anthocyanin biosynthesis. Business growers usually use ethylene-releasing brokers to advertise uniform ripening and improve colour improvement, thereby guaranteeing a constant and visually interesting crop.
In abstract, the ripening stage just isn’t merely a passive timeframe however an energetic biochemical interval essential for the manifestation of pink coloration in apples. This course of includes the activation of genetic pathways liable for anthocyanin synthesis and is influenced by quite a few inner and exterior components. Correct administration of ripening by cultural practices contributes considerably to the manufacturing of apples with the fascinating colour traits, additional underscoring its significance in understanding “why are apples pink.” Understanding the ripening course of’s impact on colour helps in creating efficient methods to maximise apple high quality.
5. Temperature Impression
Temperature exerts a big affect on anthocyanin biosynthesis, and subsequently, is essential in figuring out the depth and extent of pink coloration in lots of apple varieties. This affect operates by varied physiological and biochemical mechanisms, instantly affecting enzyme exercise and gene expression.
-
Low-Temperature Enhancement of Anthocyanin Manufacturing
Publicity to reasonably low temperatures in the course of the ripening section usually promotes anthocyanin accumulation. This phenomenon is attributed to the improved exercise of enzymes concerned within the anthocyanin biosynthetic pathway at decrease temperatures. Moreover, diminished chlorophyll degradation at cooler temperatures could not directly contribute to a extra pronounced anthocyanin show. For instance, apple orchards experiencing a interval of cool nights (round 10-15C) in the course of the last weeks earlier than harvest continuously exhibit fruits with a deeper colour depth in comparison with orchards with persistently hotter nighttime temperatures. The influence is particularly pronounced in cultivars already genetically predisposed to excessive anthocyanin manufacturing.
-
Excessive-Temperature Inhibition of Anthocyanin Synthesis
Conversely, excessively excessive temperatures can inhibit anthocyanin biosynthesis. Elevated temperatures could denature enzymes concerned within the anthocyanin pathway or suppress the expression of genes encoding these enzymes. Moreover, excessive temperatures can promote chlorophyll degradation, which could diminish the visible influence of anthocyanins, even when they’re being produced. In areas experiencing warmth waves in the course of the ripening interval, apples could exhibit a much less vibrant colour. Excessive warmth also can result in sunscald, which not solely impairs colour improvement but in addition damages the fruit’s pores and skin, making it unmarketable.
-
Diurnal Temperature Fluctuations
Day by day temperature fluctuations, notably the distinction between daytime and nighttime temperatures, can considerably influence fruit coloration. Giant diurnal temperature swings, characterised by heat days and funky nights, are likely to favor anthocyanin accumulation. The nice and cozy daytime temperatures help photosynthesis and sugar manufacturing, offering the required substrates for anthocyanin synthesis. The cool nighttime temperatures, as talked about earlier, improve enzyme exercise and cut back anthocyanin degradation. Constant temperature swings can thus result in extra intense coloration in comparison with eventualities with steady temperatures, even when the typical temperature is identical.
-
Temperature Results on Different Pigments and Fruit High quality
Temperature additionally influences the manufacturing of different pigments and compounds throughout the apple. Excessive temperatures, for instance, can speed up the ripening course of, resulting in a softer fruit texture and diminished storage life. The stability between chlorophyll degradation, anthocyanin synthesis, and carotenoid manufacturing is extremely temperature-dependent, with implications for total fruit high quality and visible enchantment. Understanding these interactions is important for creating efficient temperature administration methods in apple orchards.
In abstract, temperature performs a multi-faceted function in figuring out the colour of apples. From facilitating enzyme exercise to influencing gene expression, temperatures affect is simple. Low temperatures encourage colour improvement whereas excessive temperatures impede it. Understanding these temperature impacts is subsequently important to answering, “why are apples pink.” Such information can permit us to boost the colour and high quality of apple crops with correct rising methods.
6. Flavonoid Pigments
Flavonoid pigments represent a principal determinant of “why are apples pink.” Anthocyanins, a subclass of flavonoids, are water-soluble pigments liable for the pink, purple, and blue colours noticed in varied plant tissues, together with apple pores and skin. The presence and focus of those pigments are instantly proportional to the depth of the fruit’s coloration. Genetic components, daylight publicity, temperature, and stage of ripening all affect the synthesis and accumulation of anthocyanins, thus impacting the visible look. As an illustration, varieties like ‘Fuji’ or ‘Gala,’ that are genetically predisposed to anthocyanin manufacturing, develop a vibrant pink blush below optimum rising circumstances because of the excessive focus of those pigments of their epidermal cells.
Past their aesthetic function, flavonoid pigments, particularly anthocyanins, contribute to the general high quality of apples. These compounds possess antioxidant properties, which provide safety towards mobile injury from free radicals. Consumption of apples wealthy in anthocyanins could contribute to human well being by lowering the chance of continual ailments. Breeders usually prioritize cultivars with excessive anthocyanin content material, not just for their visible enchantment but in addition for his or her enhanced dietary worth. The event of such cultivars underscores the sensible significance of understanding the connection between flavonoid pigments and fruit traits. Particular flavonoids additionally assist defend apples from UV radiation.
In summation, flavonoid pigments, notably anthocyanins, play a significant function in figuring out the pink coloration noticed in lots of apple varieties. Their synthesis is influenced by a fancy interaction of genetic and environmental components. Understanding this interaction is essential for optimizing orchard administration practices and breeding packages. Whereas challenges stay in totally elucidating the regulatory mechanisms of anthocyanin biosynthesis, ongoing analysis continues to refine our understanding of “why are apples pink” and to unlock the potential of those worthwhile compounds for each horticultural and dietary functions. The antioxidant properties present further advantages to the plant and shopper.
7. UV Safety
The presence of anthocyanins, the flavonoid pigments liable for the pink coloration in lots of apple varieties, gives a level of ultraviolet (UV) radiation safety to the fruit. This photoprotective operate arises from the flexibility of anthocyanins to soak up UV wavelengths, thereby lowering the depth of radiation penetrating the epidermal and sub-epidermal tissues. Publicity to daylight, notably its UV element, triggers anthocyanin biosynthesis, making a suggestions loop the place elevated UV radiation stimulates the manufacturing of pigments that then mitigate its damaging results. This mechanism is much like how melanin protects human pores and skin from sunburn. The diploma of safety supplied correlates with the focus of anthocyanins; thus, extra intensely coloured fruit exhibit larger UV absorbance capability. Sure apple varieties, which develop deeper hues are thought to have excessive safety towards UV than others.
The advantages of UV safety lengthen past the quick preservation of mobile integrity throughout the fruit. By lowering UV-induced oxidative stress, anthocyanins contribute to sustaining the standard and increasing the shelf life. UV radiation can degrade varied biomolecules, together with nutritional vitamins and taste compounds, probably lowering the dietary worth and sensory attributes of the fruit. Moreover, UV publicity can speed up the breakdown of cell partitions, resulting in softening and elevated susceptibility to fungal pathogens. The presence of anthocyanins helps mitigate these results, preserving fruit firmness, style, and dietary content material throughout ripening and storage. Apple growers generally implement methods to boost UV publicity, not directly boosting the apple’s pure protecting measures and enhancing the sturdiness of the fruit.
In conclusion, UV safety is a big, although usually unspoken, facet of the connection between anthocyanins and apple coloration. The UV absorption capability of those pigments contributes not solely to the visible look but in addition to the upkeep of fruit high quality, dietary worth, and resistance to degradation. Whereas the genetic and environmental components influencing anthocyanin biosynthesis are advanced, the ensuing UV safety presents tangible advantages for each the plant and the buyer. Future analysis could discover optimizing circumstances to maximise anthocyanin content material and, consequently, improve UV safety, contributing to the manufacturing of extra resilient and nutritious apple crops.
8. Pollinator Attraction
The coloration of apple blossoms, and to a lesser extent the mature fruit, serves as a visible sign to draw pollinators, which is vital for fertilization and subsequent fruit improvement. Though the pink colour is extra pronounced within the fruit, sure varieties exhibit reddish hues of their blossoms, enjoying a job in preliminary pollinator attraction.
-
Visible Signaling and Pollinator Habits
Pollinators, similar to bees, depend on visible cues to find floral assets. The particular colours exhibited by apple blossoms, together with reddish-pink tones in some varieties, can improve their visibility towards the encompassing foliage. This visible distinction helps pollinators determine and strategy the flowers, rising the probability of profitable pollination. Bees have trichromatic imaginative and prescient, delicate to UV, blue, and inexperienced mild. Some apple varieties could have UV patterns on their petals, invisible to the human eye, which information the bees to the nectar and pollen.
-
Nectar Guides and Flower Morphology
Along with colour, the morphology of apple blossoms is tailored to facilitate pollinator entry to nectar and pollen. The form and association of petals, together with the presence of nectar guides (patterns that direct pollinators to the nectar supply), contribute to environment friendly pollen switch. Whereas colour attracts the pollinator, the flower’s bodily construction ensures efficient pollination as soon as the insect arrives. The timing of flower bloom relative to the supply of pollinators can be essential. The attractiveness of a flower can be depending on its perfume.
-
Impression on Fruit Set and Yield
Efficient pollinator attraction instantly influences fruit set, which is the share of flowers that become mature fruit. Enough pollination is important for maximizing fruit yield and high quality. Inadequate pollinator exercise may end up in diminished fruit set, smaller fruit dimension, and misshapen fruit. The colourful colour of apple blossoms, particularly when coupled with engaging scents, considerably contributes to drawing pollinators to orchards. A powerful pollination enhances productiveness.
-
Oblique Choice by Seed Dispersal
Whereas the connection between fruit colour and pollinator attraction is most direct on the blossom stage, the colour of the mature fruit performs a job in seed dispersal. The pink coloration of many apples, whereas in a roundabout way attracting pollinators, serves to draw seed dispersers, similar to birds and mammals. Dispersal of seeds by animals is vital for the growth and survival of plant populations. An oblique affect on future generations, contributing to the genetic perpetuation of colour traits helpful for each pollination and seed dispersal.
Thus, whereas the reason of “why are apples pink” relates primarily to the mature fruit and components like anthocyanin manufacturing for UV safety and seed dispersal, the connection to pollinator attraction is most pronounced in the course of the flowering stage. Nonetheless, the presence of reddish hues in some apple blossoms underscores the evolutionary strain for visible alerts that improve reproductive success by efficient pollination.
9. Visible Signaling
Visible signaling is inextricably linked to “why are apples pink,” functioning as a key mechanism in each the plant’s reproductive success and its interplay with the atmosphere. The pink coloration, primarily attributable to anthocyanin pigments, acts as a conspicuous sign, attracting seed dispersers. The event of this hue just isn’t merely a random incidence however a particular evolutionary trait as a result of it enhances the fruit’s visibility towards the inexperienced foliage. For instance, a research on bird-mediated seed dispersal confirmed a desire for pink fruits over inexperienced or yellow ones, resulting in elevated seed dispersal distances and colonization of latest habitats. The presence of the pink visible sign in mature fruits is subsequently a vital element of the plant’s survival technique.
The sensible significance of understanding this visible sign extends to agricultural practices. By manipulating environmental components, similar to mild publicity and temperature, fruit growers can optimize anthocyanin manufacturing, thereby enhancing the visible enchantment of their produce. Shopper desire research have persistently demonstrated that buyers affiliate deeper pink colours with ripeness, sweetness, and total high quality, driving market demand and financial worth. Breeders give attention to varieties identified to provide vivid coloration, using visible traits as key determinants in cross-breeding packages. Additional research additionally point out a correlation between the depth of colour and the presence of antioxidants, making visually interesting fruits extra engaging to health-conscious customers.
In abstract, visible signaling constitutes a vital aspect in comprehending “why are apples pink.” The coloration serves not solely to draw seed dispersers but in addition influences shopper desire and agricultural practices. Challenges stay in totally elucidating the advanced interaction between genetic components, environmental circumstances, and the ensuing pigment manufacturing. Nonetheless, recognizing the significance of visible alerts gives worthwhile insights into each the evolutionary biology of apples and the methods employed to domesticate them successfully, guaranteeing each their ecological function and financial worth are sustained.
Incessantly Requested Questions
The next addresses frequent inquiries concerning the components influencing the colour of apples.
Query 1: What’s the main pigment liable for the pink colour in apples?
Anthocyanins, a category of flavonoid pigments, are primarily liable for the attribute pink hue noticed in lots of apple varieties. Their focus instantly influences the depth of coloration.
Query 2: Does daylight have an effect on apple colour?
Publicity to daylight, notably ultraviolet (UV) radiation, considerably enhances anthocyanin synthesis in apples. This explains why the aspect of an apple going through the solar usually displays a extra intense pink colour.
Query 3: Are all apples genetically predisposed to be pink?
No. The genetic make-up of an apple cultivar determines its capability for anthocyanin manufacturing. Some varieties are genetically predisposed to provide excessive ranges of anthocyanins, leading to pink coloration, whereas others produce totally different pigments, resulting in yellow or inexperienced hues.
Query 4: How does temperature affect apple colour?
Reasonable temperature fluctuations, notably cool nights in the course of the ripening stage, can promote anthocyanin accumulation. Excessive temperatures, conversely, could inhibit anthocyanin synthesis.
Query 5: Does the stage of ripeness have an effect on apple colour?
Sure. Anthocyanin synthesis usually will increase in the course of the ripening stage. Because the fruit matures, the focus of those pigments intensifies, contributing to a deeper pink colour.
Query 6: Does the pink colour supply any profit to the apple?
The presence of anthocyanins gives a number of advantages, together with safety towards UV radiation and attraction of seed dispersers. Moreover, the pigments contribute to the apple’s antioxidant properties.
The pink coloration in apples outcomes from a fancy interaction of genetic and environmental components. Understanding these components is essential for optimizing orchard administration and breeding packages.
The following sections will delve into particular elements of orchard administration practices designed to boost fruit coloration.
Suggestions for Enhancing Apple Coloration
Optimizing the looks, particularly the depth of the pink coloration, of apples requires cautious administration of varied components all through the rising season. The ideas offered purpose to boost the manufacturing of anthocyanins, the important thing pigments influencing the ultimate hue.
Tip 1: Implement Strategic Pruning: Correct pruning methods are important for maximizing daylight penetration into the tree cover. Take away dense branches to permit daylight to succeed in all elements of the fruit. This will increase anthocyanin manufacturing and ends in extra uniformly coloured apples. Common pruning promotes mild distribution throughout the tree.
Tip 2: Make use of Reflective Floor Covers: Using reflective supplies on the bottom beneath the timber can considerably improve the quantity of sunshine reaching the decrease parts of the fruit. These supplies replicate daylight upwards, enhancing anthocyanin synthesis on the shaded areas, which might in any other case be much less intensely coloured. Reflective floor covers may be positioned earlier than ripening.
Tip 3: Handle Nitrogen Fertilization Rigorously: Extreme nitrogen fertilization can promote vegetative development on the expense of fruit coloration. Monitor nitrogen ranges within the soil and modify fertilization practices to keep away from over-application. A balanced nutrient provide is essential for optimum fruit improvement and colour enhancement.
Tip 4: Optimize Irrigation Practices: Water stress can negatively influence anthocyanin manufacturing. Preserve constant soil moisture ranges all through the rising season, particularly in the course of the ripening section. Nonetheless, keep away from over-watering, as this will additionally hinder colour improvement.
Tip 5: Think about Ethylene-Releasing Brokers: Ethylene promotes uniform ripening, which contributes to extra constant coloration. Making use of ethylene-releasing brokers, similar to ethephon, can speed up and synchronize the ripening course of, resulting in extra uniformly coloured fruit. Observe the directions offered by the manufactures.
Tip 6: Monitor and Management Pests and Illnesses: Infestations and ailments can stress the timber, lowering their capacity to provide anthocyanins. Implement built-in pest administration methods to reduce injury and preserve tree well being. Wholesome timber will produce higher-quality fruit with higher colour.
By implementing the following tips, apple growers can considerably improve the pink coloration of their fruit, enhancing marketability and shopper enchantment. The profitable software of those methods requires cautious monitoring and adaptation to particular environmental circumstances and apple varieties.
These strategies present the premise for enhancing the coloring and high quality of fruit which will likely be explored extra within the conclusion.
Conclusion
The exploration of “why are apples pink” reveals a fancy interaction of genetic predispositions and environmental influences. Anthocyanin manufacturing, the important thing consider producing the attribute pink hue, is ruled by intricate biochemical pathways and modulated by daylight, temperature, and the ripening stage. Cultivar-specific genetic components set the potential for coloration, whereas exterior components act as vital triggers and modifiers. Moreover, the coloration serves vital organic features, together with UV safety and seed dispersal.
Future analysis ought to give attention to additional elucidating the genetic regulatory networks governing anthocyanin biosynthesis and on creating extra exact methods for manipulating environmental circumstances to optimize fruit coloration and high quality. Continued advances in these areas will allow the manufacturing of apples with enhanced visible enchantment and dietary worth, contributing to each financial advantages for growers and well being benefits for customers. An understanding of the science that drives “why are apples pink” turns into crucial for the longer term success of the product and the buyer.
